Southwest Florida's Trusted Insurance Family
From hurricanes to horses, homes to businesses — Peeples Insurance protects what matters most. As an independent agency, we shop 95+ carriers to find you the right coverage at the best price.
Meet Pete
Your friendly guide to smarter insurance in Florida.
Years Serving Florida
Insurance Carriers
Coverage Types
Florida Offices
Insurance for Every Part of Florida Life
From your home and cars to your business and beyond, we offer 30+ coverage types tailored to Southwest Florida.
The Independent Advantage
We work for you — not the insurance companies. That means honest advice and coverage matched to your real Florida risks.
We Shop 95+ Carriers
As an independent agency, we compare dozens of top carriers to find your best coverage and price — you never have to.
Personal, Local Service
Real people who answer the phone and know Florida. Clients love that Jennifer even secured coverage on Christmas Eve.
Florida Storm Experts
Hurricane, flood, and windstorm coverage guidance rooted in 40+ years of post-Hurricane Andrew experience.
Fast Turnaround
Quotes in minutes, not months — many clients are covered the same day they call.
Ask Pete
Your AI insurance coverage guide
Ask a general insurance question and Pete will explain it in plain English. This is educational information — not a policy quote.
Backed by Florida's Insurance Community
Our memberships hold us to the highest professional and consumer-protection standards.
What Florida Families Are Saying
Real reviews from real neighbors across Sarasota, Bradenton, and Margate.
“Excellent service! I called Jennifer Peeples this morning with a homeowners insurance emergency as my previous insurance had been cancelled. After spending all the previous day on the phone with various other a…”
Angelique Bowers
Homeowners emergency — Christmas Eve
“This is the BEST insurance agency ever!! Jennifer helped me establish homeowners insurance on my rental at a great price and, most importantly, coverage that makes me feel peace of mind on my investment. My ren…”
Teddy Earl
Rental property insurance
“Absolutely amazing, positive, pleasant, professional agency. JENNIFER IS THE BEST. She got us a great quote within 30 minutes when our current agent said it would take 3 months to find an agency that would insu…”
Sharon Day
Homeowners with two dogs
Local Help, Right Around the Corner
Visit us in Sarasota, Bradenton, or Margate — or get a quote from anywhere in Florida.
Get Your Free Quote
Tell us what you'd like to protect and we'll do the shopping.